Bewertung Masterarbeit

  • Verfasser: Stephanie Hobmeier 
  • Hochschule: Kunsthochschule Kassel 
  • Typ: Diplomarbeit 
  • Studiengang Produkt-Design, Schwerpunkt System-Design 
  • Sommer- und Wintersemester 2018 

Titel der ausgewählten Arbeit:

Die Zukunft war früher auch besser: Schlüssel-Kompetenzen für sozialverantwortliches Gestalten und deren Vermittlung in der Design-Ausbildung 

Vorweg ist anzumerken, dass die Arbeit »Die Zukunft war früher auch besser« zwar von einer Studentin im Fachbereich Industrie-Design verfasst wurde, ich jedoch der Meinung bin, dieses Thema als disziplinenübergreifend zu betrachten, und sich gewiss jede DesignerIn früher oder später mit diesem auseinander setzt. 

Gestaltungshöhe 

Die visuelle Sprache der Arbeit ist für ein gestaltungsrelevantes Thema eher zurückhaltend und meiner Meinung nach von der Autorin bewusst nüchtern gehalten. Jedoch finden sich immer wieder Elemente, die dem Betrachter eine visuelle Struktur bei Text und Layout vorgeben. Die Farbe Rot und Schwarz-Weiß-Abbildungen werden zu grafischen Konstanten der Arbeit. 

Mit Farbakzenten wird auf ein neues Thema hingewiesen, ein systematisches aber dennoch nicht langweiliges Layout greift den gestalterischen Zugang zum Thema gut auf.

Innovationsgrad 

Aspekte aus verschiedenen Wissensgebieten werden für die Beantwortung der Forschungsfrage herangezogen, daher ist der Inhalt und die jeweiligen Verbindungen der relevanten Teilbereiche eine durchaus komplexe Denkleistung der Autorin. Das immer wiederkehrende Ziehen von Zwischenbilanzen ermöglicht, die komplexen Zusammenhänge der nicht designspezifischen Wissenschaftsbereiche für den Leser verständlich und angemessen aufzubereiten. Auch die Frage der Designvermittlung bzw. Lehre spielt in der Arbeit eine große Rolle. Dieser Teil der Designausbildung ist sicherlich an einigen Instituten zu hinterfragen und stellt nach meiner persönlichen Betrachtung der Arbeit einen sehr hohen Innovationsgrad dar. 

Selbstständigkeit 

Die Autorin hat die Arbeit nach eigenen Angaben nach besten Wissen und mit großer Sorgfalt verfasst. Die Autorin gibt an, die Arbeit selbstständig und ohne unzulässige Hilfsmittel verfasst zu haben. Dabei wurde sie von drei verschiedenen Betreuern unterstützt. Tabellen sowie Abbildungen wurden immer mit einer Quelle vermerkt, eigene Darstellungen sind ebenfalls als solche gekennzeichnet. 

Gliederung und Struktur 

Die Gliederung und Struktur der Arbeit ist in meinen Augen eher klassisch angelegt. Die Arbeit erfüllt grundsätzlich alle formalen Aspekte, welche für Master- oder Diplomarbeiten von Bedeutung sind. Die Schreibweise wurde nicht genderspezifisch gehalten. Wenn nicht anders möglich, wurde jedoch die maskuline Schreibweise gewählt. Für eine Arbeit, in der es um inklusive Herangehensweisen, im Bezug auf Gestaltung geht und ein Bewusstsein für Design legt, welches Mensch und Umwelt im Zentrum sieht, finde ich es persönlich naheliegend, dies auch in einer zeitgemäßen Sprache wieder zu geben.

Umfang der Arbeit 

Es werden verschiedene Teilbereiche aus Psychologie, Gestaltung und gesellschaftspolitischer Relevanz analysiert und deren Zusammenhänge in Bezug auf verantwortungsbewusstes Design zusammengeführt. Daraufhin werden die Kernkompetenzen eines reflektiert agierenden Gestalters hervorgehoben. Weiters wird analysiert, wie jene Fähigkeiten in der Lehre und Ausbildung vermittelt werden können. Als Case Study werden auch zwei Design-Studiengänge, im Bezug auf die Vermittlung von Kompetenzen, analysiert. Weiters sind drei Experteninterviews zur Beantwortung der wissenschaftlichen Fragestellung herangezogen worden. Die einzelnen Erkenntnisse werden am Ende der Arbeit in Form eines Kriterienkatalogs, für eine zeitgemäße Designausbildung, zusammengefasst.

Orthographie, sowie Sorgfalt und Genauigkeit 

Grundsätzlich macht die Arbeit einen sehr sauberen und gut gegliederten Eindruck. Die zurückhaltende Gestaltung zieht sich wie ein Faden durch die Diplomarbeit und zeigt dem Leser eine leicht zu folgende Struktur auf. Im Hinblick auf exakte Rechtschreibung, scheint die Arbeit ebenfalls mit Sorgfalt verfasst worden zu sein, jedoch liegt es mir persönlich, aufgrund meiner eigenen Kompetenzen, fern dazu eine Bewertung abzugeben.

Literatur 

Die Verfasserin der Arbeit scheint ihre Quellenangabe sehr sachlich und sorgsam angeführt zu haben. Das Literaturverzeichnis der Arbeit umfasst eine große Auswahl an Buch-, Magazin- als auch Onlinequellen.  

Analog (ca. 45) und Online (ca. 75) werden verschieden aufgelistet, weiters findet sich ein Abbildungsverzeichnis und eine Auflistung der Tabellen und Grafiken wieder. Gerade bei den verwendeten Internet-Quellen fällt auf, dass die Verfasserin vorwiegend etablierte Institutionen, Bundesministerien, Online-Lexika oder wissenschaftliche Artikel zitiert. Alle Quellen sind mit Link und Datum versehen.

Quelle: https://www.wusgermany.de/sites/wusgermany.de/files/content/files/hobmeier_diplomarbeit.pdf

Call to action

“Every time you spend money, you’re casting a vote for the kind of world you want”. – A quote by Anna Lappe, author, and educator. She is known as an expert on food systems and sustainable food production. [1]

So thinking about “The call to action” for my campaign, I had to define what each consumer can do to support people in digital labor employments. How can consumers be a part of a change in the system? Money for sure is an option, but the idea that we as a society have to jump in financially is just not vindicated and would support the corrupt manner those companies live by.  Nothing less than a change in the system is needed, so companies have to follow certain standards, nevertheless they are selling a service online or offline. 

So telling people not to order from companies like Amazon or food delivery services might be a solution, but people also want to support their favorite restaurants during the pandemic or are forced to order stuff online because of lockdowns. Also, real people depend on the jobs, so stop consuming these services might not be the solution. 

So for the call to action, I came up with the idea of an online petition, people can sign and participate. In exchange for taking part and supporting full standards for digital labor, participants receive a sticker that they can put on their doors. As the “door” itself is a metaphor for closed opportunities, the sicker is a sign of opening up and supporting the delivery drivers. 

With the claim – I am open for change (+QR Code) – the sicker shows that people are aware of the worker’s situation and support them. 

[1] https://annalappe.com/about/

My own emotional branding case – Part 2

For my own emotional branding case, I decided to create an idea of a campaign for bringing the often harsh working conditions for employees of digital labor into the spotlight.

There are different kinds of digital labor, but I decided to focus on the often tough working conditions for delivery drivers. During the pandemic, people all over the world depended on their service, but still, they have not received the appreciation they deserve for their commitment especially in times like this. 

Due to the fact that the concept of digital labor is still new, a lot of companies that operate in the field try to find loopholes to save money on the costs of employing somebody. Therefore a lot of these workers aren’t fully ensured and often have to take care of their working gadgets, like transportation on their own.  

As a symbol of opportunity, the door is in the spotlight of my campaign. Delivery guys run the whole day from door to door, hand over packages or food deliveries. But those doors just open up just for a short moment to transfer goods. The same metaphor is used for the “door” to fair working conditions, and to receive a salary so people are able to make a living out of it. 

Pictures from www.unsplash.com

My own emotional branding case – Part 1

After researching the different aspects of emotion in design and branding, I take the next step and decide to create my own fictional case. For that, I took some time and started to look for a brand or organization that could take the role of the client for my campaign. Because of my interest in politics and social issues, I decided to inform myself about digital labour and new ways of work. Through the United Nations website, I found out about the International Labour Organisation (ILO), which understands itself as an intersection between governments, employers and workers. It consists out of 187 member states and promotes new standards for labour and respectable working conditions.

The ILO uses its platform to raise awareness for a diverse field of different problems, like digital labor platforms and how workers are treated. Digital apps like Uber or Liferando seem to have failed when it comes to worker’s rights and protection. The delivery drivers are treated as independent contractors, with no social benefits like pension coverage, health, or insurance plans. Due to the pandemic, the problems of those delivery drivers became even worse. Especially the situation in emerging countries continues to be tough and no safety measures to prevent a covid infection are taken. I think it is important to raise awareness of this topic and to support the IOL in their strive for better working conditions.

Links:

https://www.ilo.org/global/standards/lang–en/index.htm

https://voices.ilo.org/stories/time-to-deliver-decent-work-in-digital-labour-platforms

Branded content

Branded content is a form of creating brand stories that have a non-product or non-service focussed storyline. The brand itself and the values are the focus of the message. 

In times where it’s more and more important as a brand to tell a unique story, the mainstream channels were to reach consumers are outdated. The audience, that is forced to watch tv commercials is about to decrease. Through the rise of on-demand streaming platforms, ad blockers, and blind watching, the ad itself is harder to bring to potential consumers. Branded content tries to turn the idea of classic commercials around. It transforms from something you had to watch into something you want to watch. It also comes in a new variety of mediums. Podcasts, video games, or in forms of getting involved with the consumer directly. Branded content tries to put the brand’s history in the foreground and communicate its values in a way that is appealing to the customer even beyond the product. Through this approach of creating content, brands can stay relevant, independently from the product or service they are selling. Especially for reaching young adults, branded content is interesting. They are the ones who consume less established media, like classic tv or radio, so brands need to adapt their forms of communication. A new generation of consumers is interested in how brands deal with social, racial, and environmental issues. Furthermore, the covid crises chanced the way we consume in a radical way and brands need to react on that to stay relevant. 

Link: www.shots.net/news/view/why-branded-content-is-the-future

A new generation of consumers

While emotional branding and the “tribe” that comes with it worked for previous generations, the GenZ seems to be different. Generation Z is born between 1997-2015 and is the first fully grown digital generation. Therefore their personal expression differs from previous generations. The digital self comes to the fore. Regarding consumption habits, GenZ tends to be more aware of environmental and social issues. Second-hand shopping and renting mobility devices are more common than the desire of calling certain products their own. Studies show that a majority of this generation thinks that companies have a social and environmental responsibility, so they are more likely to choose brands that are aware of these issues and set actions. GenZ also searches for individuality, when it comes to consumption. Their own individual identity is at the center of their decisions. So they reach for brands that underline that individual expression. 

In the future, it will be much more important that brands get active and become aware of their actions and responsibilities, and do their part. Through the possibility of access to information it will get easier for consumers to recognized inauthenticity in a brand’s behavior and actions, so to stay or become relevant brands need to deal with these topics. 

Link: www.shots.net/news/view/for-gen-z-consumption-is-about-self-expression

Picture: www.commbox.io/the-customer-service-experience-for-millennials-and-gen-z/

What is emotional branding?

Brands use emotional branding to create a connection between the brand and the consumer by using emotions in a specific way. Advertisers try to generate content that can be triggered by a consumer’s personality, needs, goals, or experiences. It also describes a supportive tool in marketing that is used to strengthen a brand’s perception. It helps to support the brand’s identity and public image. In a world, with global competitors, it’s important for brands to deliver an individual language and gain the trust of the consumer. Emotional branding gives the brand a character and makes it possible to pull clear from competitors. The goal is to create full brand loyalty towards the consumer. 

BBC-story-works did research on the topic of emotional branding. In “The science of memory” the researchers describe how brands can create big moments in advertising that can manifest themselves in the consumer’s long-term memory. The study proves that if very personal stories or experiences of a protagonist in advertisements are promoted, the consumer connects these emotions to the brand. Especially if the issues portrayed are somehow relevant for the individual consumer. 

Emotional branding is an important tool not only for the brand’s image itself but also for a new generation of consumers, that tend to be more interested in a brand’s social and environmental attitude than generations before. 

Links:

www.bbcglobalnews.com/media/3174/bbc-science-of-memory-2018.pdf 

www.marconomy.de/emotional-branding-warum-marken-geschichten-erzaehlen-a-832350/ 

Next Step: Building an Emotional Connection?

More and more waste is created all over the world from products that are replaced in shorter time periods. People tend to use certain products only for a minimum time, even though they still work perfectly fine. Some of the things land right in the garbage can others are placed in boxes or drawers. In these things lies a huge potential. The user is committed to the product but lost the emotional connection to it. This means that the product can still gain the attention of the owner/user back. Designers can help to support building this emotional relation from a product to the user. The goal is that people keep their products to extend the time of active usage. We know how to create and construct things that last for many years but how can we activate people to use their products longer and therefore extend the lifetime of a product? As designers, we can help to create emotions and boost the relationship between the consumer and the product/service. For the field of communication design, it’s important to detect the upcoming problems the world is facing and to find creatives ways to communicate them. 

Climate Crisis Foto: (Jonathan Nackstrand) / AFP
Child Poverty (Keepearth.com)
Global Pandemic (Picture alliance/ZUMA Press)
Organization: Moms Demand Action (AP Photo/Brennan Linsley)

Emotion in advertising

When it comes to emotion in advertising many people tend to think that this is all about making an unspectacular product more interesting or trying to sell a certain feeling connected to a product. But on a scientific level, it is more complex, than most people are aware of. In a world of globalized mass production, consumer decisions are more and more based on various criteria. Measuring emotional design and how it creates awareness for a certain topic is much harder to capture. 

When we think of emotions in advertising, we mostly associate good feelings and moods. But emotions in design are not always positive. The strongest emotions humans can detect are negative feelings like disgust, anger, fear, or sadness. If this information is not helpful to advertise a brand’s product it can help to raise awareness for issues like climate change, poverty, gender equality, or health issues. Most advertisers are following this approach because the institute of practitioners in advertising found out that when an ad is successful on an emotional level it is likely to double results on sales. Furthermore, depending on the topic, it can also lead to a wide discourse on social, environmental, or ethical problems and create awareness. The specific use of emotions in ads is also studied by scientific researchers. Ads based on emotions can lead to a more deeper and durable indentation on the memory center of the brain. For this research, marketers are using methods like facial coding, implicit response testing, eye tracking, and MRI. 

Charitywater Campaign
 New Ark Mission of India
Colin Kaepernick for Nike
Moms demand action

www.contently.com/2016/04/14/dangerous-power-emotional-advertising/

www.designwissen.net/voll-im-trend-emotionen-und-emotional-design/

Emotional Sustainability

Emotional sustainability deals with the emotionally triggered part of a product/service or campaign, while physical sustainability describes the durability, functionality, and material usage of a certain product or service. As humans act individually it’s important for creators to generate products and services that assemble both aspects of design. Emotional sustainability describes the “human-centered component of design”. This difference is crucial when it comes to recycling a product. It’s not only about the material that is used, but also about the emotional component of the product or service. If a product or service can combine both aspects, emotional and physical sustainability it is more steady in it is design proposal and result. Emotional sustainability is also connected to a “supra-functional” approach. That means that a product/service is also emotional, cultural, and socially conscious. Emotional sustainability creates a more meaningful design approach that is crucial in a time where user awareness and sustainability are mandatory. 

www.experts.illinois.edu/en/publications/emotional-sustainability

www.productmanagementfestival.com/emotional-sustainability-in-brand-and-product-design/